Title: How to assess a payment application | Livo Assistant
Source: https://livoassistant.com/guides/assess-payment-application

A guide for the person assessing an interim valuation: what to check, payment notice and pay less notice rules, JCT and NEC4 timings, and a 15-point checklist.

---

Guide · Construction

# How to assess a payment application

Published November 19, 2026

To assess a payment application, compare each line with the work done, the contract rates and the amounts already paid. Then issue your payment notice, and any pay less notice, on time and with the basis for every reduction. Most guidance explains how a contractor submits an application. This guide is for the person on the other side: the QS, cost consultant, employer's agent or NEC project manager who has to decide what is due.

_This is a practical guide, not legal advice. Check your own contract and take legal advice on notices and deadlines. _

## What are you deciding when you assess an application?

You decide two things: the sum you consider due at the due date, and the basis on which you calculated it. The Construction Act asks for both in the notice you give ( [section 110A](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/53/section/110A)). A basis you cannot trace to a document is weak.

## What should an interim valuation check?

Work through the application in this order.

- **Work done. **Is the cumulative value of work in place supported by measurement, inspection or progress records? The default Scheme values work performed from commencement to the end of the period, then subtracts what has been paid or is due ( [Scheme, Part II, paragraph 2](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1998/649/schedule/part/II)).
- **Quantities against the contract. **Know whether the price follows measurement or fixed prices. Under NEC4 Option B, work done is completed quantities at bill rates. Under Option A it is the prices of completed activities. A quantity above the bill is a measurement question on the first and an instruction question on the second.
- **Rates. **Compare each rate with the contract sum analysis, bill of quantities or schedule of rates. Check that new items are priced on a basis the contract allows.
- **Variations and compensation events. **Include only those instructed or accepted, at your own assessed amount, and look for work counted twice.
- **Materials on and off site. **The default Scheme counts materials manufactured on site or brought onto site only where the contract provides for payment for materials (paragraph 2(2)(b)). Check what your contract says about materials off site.
- **Retention. **Check the rate, the base it applies to, and any release.
- **Previous payments. **Reconcile to what was actually paid, not to what the last valuation said.
- **Arithmetic. **Re-add the columns and check carry-forwards.

## What do the payment rules require of the assessor?

**The Construction Act. **Part II of the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996, as amended by the Local Democracy, Economic Development and Construction Act 2009, sets the frame for most construction contracts in England, Wales and Scotland. The 2009 amendments, including the payment notice and pay less notice rules below, apply only to contracts entered into on or after 1 October 2011 in England and Wales and 1 November 2011 in Scotland ( [2009 Act, section 149](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2009/20/section/149)). Older contracts keep the original 1996 rules. Scotland has its own Scheme; the defaults below are the England and Wales Scheme. Northern Ireland and Ireland have separate regimes (see the end of this section).

- A party is entitled to stage payments unless the work is under 45 days ( [section 109](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/53/section/109)).
- The contract must say how payments fall due and set a final date for payment ( [section 110](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/53/section/110)).
- The contract must require a payment notice no later than five days after the payment due date. The payer, a specified person (often the contract administrator or QS) or the payee gives it. It states the sum considered due and how it was c alculated. The sum can be zero ( [section 110A](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/53/section/110A)).
- If the payer's notice is missing, the payee may give a default notice, and the final date for payment moves back by the delay ( [section 110B](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/53/section/110B)).
- The payer must pay the notified sum by the final date for payment. To pay less, it must give a pay less notice, with the sum and its basis, within the period the parties agreed. If they did not agree one, the Scheme's period applies ( [section 111](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1996/53/section/111n1)).

In plain terms: if no valid notice is given in time, the contractor's figure can become the sum you must pay. Treat the deadlines as part of the assessment.

**The Scheme for Construction Contracts. **It fills gaps where the contract is silent or does not comply. Its defaults are in the table below: due date (paragraph 4), final date for payment (paragraph 8), payment notice (paragraph 9) and pay less notice (paragraph 10) ( [Part II](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/1998/649/schedule/part/II)).

**JCT and NEC4. **Standard forms set their own timings. Compare them with the defaults.

Scheme default JCT Standard Building Contract 2016 NEC4 ECC with option Y(UK)2 Due date later of 7 days after period and payee's claim 7 days after the interim valuation date 7 days after the assessment date Notice of the sum due payment notice within 5 days of due date certificate within 5 days of due date (clause 4.9) Project Manager certifies within 1 week of assessment date (clause 51.1) Final date for payment 17 days after due date 14 days after due date 14 days after due date Pay less notice 7 days before final date 5 days before final date 7 days before final date

The JCT and NEC columns show standard timings as published. Contract particulars and Contract Data can change them, and many contracts are amended. Read yours. JCT Design and Build is built differently from the Standard Building Contract, so check its notice mechanics in your contract rather than reading across from the table. Under NEC4 ECC, clause 50.1 has the Project Manager assess the amount due at each assessment date.

RICS publishes "Interim valuations and payment", first issued in 2015 and reissued in April 2025 as practice information. It covers payment mechanisms, retention and valuation.

**Wales, Northern Ireland and Ireland. **In Wales, a 2023 order ( [SI 2023/475](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/wsi/2023/475/made)) takes certain water-industry infrastructure contracts out of Part II. It does not cover ordinary building contracts. Northern Ireland has its own legislation, the Construction Contracts (Northern Ireland) Order 1997, with payment notice and pay less notice rules added from 14 November 2012. Ireland's Construction Contracts Act 2013 works differently. The contractor delivers a payment claim notice within 5 days of the payment claim date. A payer who contests the amount must respond within 21 days of that date, stating the amount proposed, the reasons for the difference and the basis of the calculation ( [section 4](https://www.irishstatutebook.ie/eli/2013/act/34/section/4/enacted/en/html)). Check which regime applies.

## A worked example: two findings from a public-works audit

Amounts are in Indian rupees, as in the source documents (1 lakh = 100,000), and are not converted. Quantities and percentages carry over unchanged.

The construction tour on this site holds findings from an audit of Indian public works. The data is anonymised and the contracts are not UK forms, but the checks are ones a UK assessor runs.

**Quantity above the contract. **In [one finding](https://livoassistant.com/demos/construction/findings/silt-clearance-was-paid-18-09-pct-beyond-the), a final bill paid 64,113.10 cubic metres of silt clearance against an agreement quantity of 54,290.12. That is 18.09% more. The excess, 9,822.98 cubic metres at ₹33.56, comes to ₹3,29,659. No variation or revised sanction was on file. A general clause saying quantities may vary was not treated as a sanction. The finding cites the bill, measurement book and agreement pages, and says the entries and the site need checking.

In a UK valuation the same question arises on cumulative quantities. Where the price follows measurement, ask whether a measurement supports the quantity. Where it does not, ask whether an instruction or compensation event changed the scope. Either way, see the document.

**Rates with no basis. **In [another finding](https://livoassistant.com/demos/construction/findings/extra-items-worth-rs-83-66-507-were-paid), two extra items were paid at ₹83,66,507 between them. No rate analysis or schedule line was on file for either rate. In a UK valuation this is a variation or compensation event priced without a stated basis. Under NEC4 the assessment starts from Defined Cost (clause 63.1). Under JCT the contract's valuation rules for variations apply. Look for the basis before you accept the number.

## How do you assess a compensation event?

A short answer for NEC4 ECC users. Compensation events run in sequence: definition (clause 60), notification (61), quotation (62), assessment (63 and 64) and implementation (65). A quotation contains a change to the Prices and a change to the Completion Date and any Key Dates. Clause 63.1 assesses the change to the Prices from Defined Cost: actual Defined Cost of work done by the dividing date, forecast Defined Cost of work not yet done, and the resulting Fee. Check that the Contractor split actual from forecast at the right dividing date, did not use tendered rates unless both parties agreed, and stated the time effect. Read the contract for the period at each step.

## Payment application review checklist

- Write down the due date, the payment notice deadline, the final date for payment and the pay less deadline the day the application arrives.
- Confirm who gives the notice (you, the employer or the contract administrator) and in what form. If nothing is due, plan a nil notice.
- Confirm the contract documents are current: particulars, amendments, and the register of instructions or compensation events.
- Check the application is for the right period and is cumulative to date.
- Match each line's work in place to measurement, inspection or progress records.
- Flag any cumulative quantity above the bill or the lump sum breakdown. Ask for the measurement or the instruction.
- Compare every rate with the contract rate, sum analysis or schedule of rates.
- Check that new items have a priced basis the contract allows.
- Include only variations and compensation events that are instructed or accepted, and check none is counted twice.
- Check time-related items and preliminaries against progress.
- Check materials on and off site against what the contract allows to be paid.
- Check retention: rate, base, and any release.
- Reconcile previous payments to the amounts actually paid.
- Apply deductions and set-offs, each with its own stated basis. Re-add all the arithmetic.
- Record the document and page behind every reduction, so the notice states the sum and its basis.

## Can software help with this?

It can take repeat work out of items 5 to 14. Livo Assistant checks bills, measurements and contracts against each other and against the work delivered. Rules check quantities, rates, dates and arithmetic. AI reads the documents and raises judgement items. A human reviewer approves every finding, and each cites the document and page, the same trail a notice needs. It does not replace your judgement.

## See these checks on a sample project

The 3-minute construction tour opens Livo's review desk on an anonymised public-works audit: each observation, the rule behind it and the source page. No sign-up.

[Take the construction tour →](https://livoassistant.com/demos/construction/)[Book a call →](https://livoassistant.com/guides/assess-payment-application#book)

See also: [construction billing audit with Livo](https://livoassistant.com/infrastructure)and [how a pilot works](https://livoassistant.com/pilot).

This guide is general information for professionals, not legal, tax or engineering advice. Requirements depend on your contract, project and jurisdiction.

Book a call: [pick a 30-minute slot with a founder on Calendly](https://calendly.com/kangana-livoassistant/30min?utm_source=livoassistant.com&utm_medium=website&utm_campaign=no-js-booking).
